Sued by Manning Law, APC
AccessibilityChecker.org is not a law firm and this page is not legal advice. Facts below come from public court records and published reports. Speak to a licensed attorney about your case.
Who is Manning Law
Manning Law, APC is a plaintiff-side law firm in Orange County, California. The State Bar lists its address as 26100 Towne Centre Drive, Foothill Ranch, CA 92610 (State Bar of California). It was founded by Joseph R. Manning Jr. Other attorneys who appear on its filings include Michael Manning and Craig G. Cote (Karlin Law; Law360).
The firm is one of the largest filers of disability-access lawsuits in California, covering both websites and physical premises such as parking lots and entrances. It represented the plaintiff in Robles v. Domino’s Pizza, the case in which the federal appeals court for the Ninth Circuit held in 2019 that the ADA can apply to a business’s website and app. The US Supreme Court declined to review it. The firm also brings website privacy (CIPA) claims (Captain Compliance).
Check what your complaint is about. If it says a blind or visually impaired person could not use your website with screen-reading software, this page is for you. If it is about your parking lot, entrance, counters or restrooms, it is a physical-access claim: the 72-hour steps below still apply, but the fix is a building one, not a website one.
Manning Law usually files on behalf of a small group of repeat plaintiffs. In website cases in 2026 these include Michael Sandoval, Perla Mageno, Jesus Torres, Jennifer Carbine, Rebecca Hernandez and Sheila Biglang-Awa-Castro (EcomBack mid-year 2026). If one of these names is on your complaint, it likely came from this firm.
How Many Website Accessibility Cases They File
Manning Law is one of the two busiest website accessibility filers in the US. In 2025 it filed 615 website suits, about one in six of all those tracked nationwide (TestParty, citing EcomBack). In the first half of 2026 it filed more than in the same period of 2025, and it has filed at least 29 every month this year.
| Period | Cases | Rank | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jan–Sep 2026 | About 560 (531 Jan–Aug + 29 Sep) | 2nd in Sep (14.5% of filings) | EcomBack, Sep 2026 |
| Jul 2026 | 91 (34.7% of all filings that month) | 1st | EcomBack, Jul 2026 |
| Jan–Jun 2026 | 366 (17.9%), up from 287 in Jan–Jun 2025; 55 to 75 a month | 2nd | EcomBack mid-year 2026 |
| 2025 | 615 (15.6% of 3,948) | Top filer | TestParty, citing EcomBack |
The plaintiffs are prolific too. Michael Sandoval was the most active website plaintiff in the US in 2025, with 241 suits, and filed 166 more in the first half of 2026. Perla Mageno was the top plaintiff in both 2022 (199 suits) and 2023 (172).
Where they file: Mostly the Superior Court of California, especially Los Angeles County. Some cases go to the federal court for the Central District of California (ADACompliance.net).
What the Complaint Typically Asks For
A Manning Law website complaint says a legally blind person tried to use your website with a screen reader, ran into barriers, and was kept from using your website and your physical location. The example below is a Los Angeles Superior Court complaint filed for Perla Mageno against a restaurant group, dated March 2025 and later attached to a federal case (Mageno v. Mon Restaurant Group, via CourtListener; an older version: (example complaint).
Laws cited
- California Unruh Civil Rights Act (Civil Code § 51 et seq.), as the only cause of action.
- ADA Title III (42 U.S.C. § 12181 et seq.), brought in through Civil Code § 51(f), which makes any ADA violation an Unruh Act violation.
- Court rulings that link the website to the physical business, including Thurston v. Midvale and Robles v. Domino’s.
Barriers typically alleged
- images, links and buttons with no label or alt text
- too few headings to navigate the page
- a menu the screen reader can’t read
- a checkout the plaintiff couldn’t complete
- the keyboard cursor getting stuck (“cursor traps”)
- more general problems: no keyboard access, unlabeled form fields, inaccessible PDFs
What it asks the court to order
- A declaration that the website discriminates against blind users.
- An injunction requiring the website to be made accessible. In the example complaint, the cost of that work is capped at $50,000.
- At least $4,000 in statutory damages per violation under Civil Code § 52(a), plus a further $4,000 per violation as deterrence damages.
- Attorney’s fees, costs and interest, and a jury trial.
The example complaint caps damages at $24,999 per offense and says it makes no claim about the physical premises. In practice most cases settle. One reported example: a $25,000 demand negotiated down to $10,000; another business agreed to pay $14,000 (Disability Scoop, May 2026).
What to Do In the First 72 Hours
The clock starts when you are served, so the first three days are for finding out your deadline, getting help and recording how your site looks now. They are not for fixing the website.
- Find your response deadline. In California state court you generally have 30 days after service to respond; in federal court it is 21 days (JMBM via Legal 500). Write the date down.
- Don’t ignore it, and don’t call the plaintiff’s firm yourself. If nobody responds, the court can enter a default judgment against you.
- Tell your insurer. Some general liability, cyber or employment practices policies cover ADA claims, depending on policy wording and only if you report the claim promptly.
- Talk to an ADA defense attorney, ideally one who handles Unruh Act cases in California. They can tell you whether to settle, fight or move to dismiss. Our directory of ADA defense attorneys is a starting point.
- Record the website as it is today. Before anyone changes anything, take dated screenshots and save copies of the pages named in the complaint. Your lawyer may need them.
- Find out what is actually wrong. Run a free accessibility scan to compare the barriers in the complaint with what is really on your site. That tells you and your lawyer how big the fix is.
- Check for other claims. Search your business name in court records. The same website can draw suits from more than one plaintiff, and settling with one may not stop the next.
Don’t rely on an overlay widget as the fix. In 2025 the FTC took action against the overlay vendor accessiBe over its compliance claims. A widget doesn’t change the code that screen readers read, so fix the site itself.
How to Fix the Website
Manning Law complaints point to the W3C accessibility guidelines, and the court rulings they cite ordered websites brought up to WCAG 2.0 Level AA. Fix to WCAG 2.1 AA, which includes every 2.0 AA requirement, and keep proof that you did. Many of these complaints are against restaurants and small shops, so the menu, ordering and checkout pages matter most.
| Common barrier | What it means | The fix (WCAG 2.1) |
|---|---|---|
| Images, links and buttons with no label | The screen reader says “image”, “link” or “button” and nothing else | Add alt text and accessible names that say what each one does (1.1.1, 2.4.4, 4.1.2) |
| Too few headings | Users can’t jump between sections | Mark up real headings in a logical order (1.3.1, 2.4.6) |
| Menu the screen reader can’t read | The menu is an image or a scanned PDF | Publish the menu as HTML text, or as a tagged, accessible PDF (1.1.1, 1.3.1) |
| Checkout can’t be completed | Fields have no labels; errors aren’t announced; buttons can’t be reached | Label every field, announce errors in text, make every step keyboard-operable (1.3.1, 2.1.1, 3.3.1, 3.3.2, 4.1.2) |
| Cursor traps | Pop-ups, carousels or embedded widgets trap keyboard focus | Make sure focus can always move in and out, with visible focus (2.1.2, 2.4.7) |
The remediation plan
- Scan the whole site, starting with the home page, menu, ordering or booking, cart and checkout.
- Fix critical issues first: anything that blocks buying, booking or contacting you.
- Test by hand with a screen reader (JAWS or NVDA on Windows, VoiceOver on Mac) and keyboard only. The complaints describe JAWS users, and automated scans don’t catch everything.
- Publish an accessibility statement with a contact for reporting problems.
- Keep dated reports of each scan and fix. Your lawyer can use them to show the site has been fixed.
- Re-scan monthly. New pages, menus and plugins bring the problems back.
Get Help With Your Website and Your Case
Talk to us. We’ll fix your website and connect you with an ADA defense lawyer.
A Manning Law complaint is two problems at once: a legal claim that needs a lawyer, and a website that needs fixing. We can help with both.
We fix the website. We review your site against WCAG 2.1 AA, the standard behind these complaints, and fix the issues in your site’s code rather than adding an overlay. You get dated reports showing what was fixed and when, which your lawyer can use.
We connect you with a defense lawyer. If you don’t have counsel yet, we’ll put you in touch with an attorney who handles ADA and Unruh Act website cases in California.